Logo of Green Alternatives to Incineration in Scotland - picture of Scottish flag with flames behind cross of Saint Andrew.

Title banner - Green Alternatives to Incineration in Scotland

A campaign for sustainable methods of waste management


 

  The Web This site


web counter
web counter

Dundee, biomass burner

 

Campaign group: 

RATTS - http://www.ratts.org.uk/index.html 

Artist's impression - click to enlarge

Location map - click to see larger version

Applicant: 

Forth Energy

Technology: 

Energy from Waste

Fuel

Biomass consisting of imported wood

Capacity: 

approximately 1 million tonnes per annum, power output 125MW

Local authority: 

City of Dundee Council

Planning application

Click here to see Dundee Consent Application

Status of current application: 

Application submitted to Scottish Government on 17 Aug 2010. The public had until 24 Sept to object. Statutory consultees followed with their comments by the end of Jan 2011. 

Click here to see consultee responses.

Latest News -  Please email relevant news stories for publishing 

Alert your MSP to biomass dangers, 4 Nov 2011
Click here to send letter to your MSP - Forth Energy has applied for planning permission for four large biomass power stations in Scotland: in Dundee, Grangemouth, Leith (Edinburgh) and Rosyth...read more

Forth Energy campaigners to protest in September
Campaigners in Edinburgh are planning a march, cycle ride and rally against Forth Energy's four biomass power station plans in Leith, Grangemouth, Rosyth and Dundee...read more

Dundee student fined over biomass protest — then graduates 24 hours later, 24 June - external link
A Dundee University student graduated only 24 hours after she was fined for protesting against plans to build biomass generators at four Scottish sites, including Dundee...read more

Dundee biomass plant plans put on hold while parties agree air quality monitoring programme, 20 June 2011 - external link
Controversial plans to build a biomass generator at Dundee docks could be held up for months while a programme of air quality monitoring takes place...read more

Forth Energy biomass proposals, update 13 June 2011
Dundee – suspended pending the applicant submitting further information, this information is expected to be submitted in 2012. Grangemouth – the applicant has submitted...read more

MSP calls for biomass plant air quality answers, 31 May 2011 - external link
Controversial plans for a biomass plant in Dundee are under fresh scrutiny after a local MSP demanded immediate answers on air quality concerns...read more

Biomass Firm's Planning Call, 11 May 2011

The Company behind plans for a biomass plant at Dundee harbour...read more

Forth Energy’s ‘Renewable’ energy plans not green, say environmentalists, 26 April 2011

The biomass plant proposed for Dundee would burn up to one million tonnes of imported wood each year...read more

American groups objects to Forth Energy biomass plans, 30 March - external link

Open letter of objection to Forth Energy’s plans for construction and operation of four biomass power stations: Dundee, Grangemouth...read more

Forth Energy denies any government bias in biomass plant plans, 7 March 2011 (external link to Dundee Courier)
Forth Energy, the company behind the biomass proposal for Dundee harbour, has insisted there is no bias in its favour from the government's Energy Consents Unit (ECU).

Campaigners claim objections snub, 3 February 2011 - external link

Campaigners against Forth Energy's biomass plant at Dundee harbour have expressed dismay at....read more

Dundee objections mismanaged, claim campaigners, 2 February 2011

Objectors to Forth Energy's Dundee biomass plans claim Scottish Government treatment of objections amounts to mismanagement and possible bias

Council wants answers before giving biomass plan response, 25 January, 2011 (external link)
Dundee City Council wants Scottish ministers to defer plans for the controversial biomass plant at the harbour until more information is available about its impact on public health and the environment...read more

NHS Tayside says biomass plant plan raises health fears, 24.Jan 2011 
NHS Tayside has raised serious concerns over possible health risks related to the proposed biomass plant planned for Dundee's docks area...read more

Councillor breaks silence to confirm opposition to biomass plant, 24 Jan 2011
Dundee councillor George Regan has spoken out in opposition to the proposed biomass plant at the harbour and said "Dundonians will not thank us" if it goes ahead...read more

RATTs claim thousands of letters supporting biomass protest, 23 Jan 2011 
Thousands of letters of objection -- the "vast majority" from Dundee people -- will be submitted to the Scottish Government today in protest at Forth Energy's plans for a biomass plant at the city's harbour...read more

Two sides to the biomass debate, 19 Jan 2011

SO AFTER almost a year of being invisible on the subject, there's finally no hiding place for Dundee's councUlors. On Monday they will be forced into giving an opinion on proposals to site an incinerator at the city's waterfront.

Friends of the Earth attack biomass proposals, winter 2010

Friends of the Earth Scotland have declared their opposition to large-scale biomass burning, with particular focus on Forth Energy’s proposals for Dundee, Leith, Grangemouth and Rosyth. 

Letter of objection to Dundee biomass burner, 30 August 2010

We sent the following letter today to the Scottish Government, objecting to the proposed biomass burner in Dundee: ...read more

Biomass plans fuel fear of 'neo-colonial land grab' in Africa, 30 Aug

The company behind plans to build a massive biomass plant in Dundee has said all of its fuel will come from sustainable sources. A report by...read more

A month to object to Dundee biomass burner, 25 August 2010

Objectors have until 24 September to object to plans to build an electricity generator in Dundee which will burn 1.25 million tonnes of biomass each year (mostly wood, straw, paper and card). Instructions for how to object are found here -...read more

Dundee biomass plant plans to be lodged today, 17 August 2010

Plans to build a biomass plant at the port of Dundee will be lodged with the Scottish Government today. The site of the proposed biomass plant for Dundee's docks. Forth Energy, the company...read more

Dundee, Leith, Rosyth, Grangemouth burners - update 9 July

Forth Energy have not formally submitted any application yet, but we are expecting these imminently.  The four plants have all been through the Scottish Government Scoping process and the Dundee plant...read more

Dundee biomass plant to use waste in its fuel, 14 June 2010

FORTH ENERGY, the company behind plans to build a biomass plant at Dundee’s waterfront, has confirmed that it will seek a permit allowing it to burn waste materials in the fuel mix. That...read more

MEETING HEARS OF BIOMASS PLANT 11 June 2010

THE GUEST speaker at last Tuesday's meeting of Broughty Ferry Community Council in the Public Library was Calum Wilson, of Forth Energy, who hope to build a biomass plant in the docks area of Dundee.

Biomass Plant Toxic Wood Fear, 2 June 2010

Dundee could end up the only UK city with two waste incinerators if Forth Energy uses preservative-treated wood in its planned biomass plant, it emerged today (writes Bruce Robbins). Read more....

Update - the story so far and future proceedings, 28 May 2010

In August 2009 Forth Energy, a partnership between Scottish & Southern Energy and Forth Ports, announced plans for 4 large biomass-fuelled electricity generators in Dundee, Leith, Grangemouth and Rosyth....read more  

Dundee biomass plans go on display, 21 May 2010
Plans for a controversial biomass plant and two 127-metre wind turbines in Dundee have gone on display to the public at the Overgate Centre..Read more

Dundee Courier publishes letter about health implications of biomass burner, 3 May 2010

'Deadly bi-products of incinerators', by Michael Gallagher - Sir,-I am glad to see The Courier is keeping a wary eye on plans to build a biomass burner in Dundee (April 26, leader column). Forth Energy has not said how many tonnes of biomass will be burnt each year but a 100MW biomass burner in Texas...Read more... 

Scottish Ministers publish Scoping Opinions on Forth Energy's 4 biomass burner proposals, 29 April 2010

Scottish Ministers have published Scoping Opinions on the four biomass burners proposed by Forth Energy, including Leith, Grangemouth, Dundee and Rosyth. The purpose of the document is to provide guidance for the applicant in drafting its Environmental Impact Assessment (part of the planning application process). Read more....

Related articles and reports

Fresh doubts over Leith Biomass plant, 1 July 2011 - external link
Energy Minister questions whether large-scale biomass is good for planet or economy...read more

Power plant protesters fined after bringing docks to a standstill, 22 June 2011 - external link
Four demonstrators have been fined a total of £850 after laying siege to Grangemouth docks in a protest against...read more

Carcinogenic Dioxins and Biomass Wood Combustion - letter to Guardian, 21 June 2011
Dear Mr Williamson - I live on the west coast of Scotland in the shadow of the UPM-Kymmene Caledonian paper mill and biomass power plant in Shewalton...read more

Biomass jobs cost £1-2 million each, 21 June 2011
Hi - The Coedbach Action Team, who successfully campaigned against two proposed 50 MW import-reliant biomass power stations proposed in Wales, forwarded me their evidence...read more 

Burning Question: Why is PKC incinerating more of our household waste? Perthshire Advertiser, 31 May 2011
SHOCK figures have revealed that Perth and Kinross Council is incinerating more of our household waste...read more (n.b. this is relevant to Dundee, because Perth and Kinross Council is sending waste to the DERL incinerator at Baldovie.)

Springfield revokes biomass consent, 26 May 2011
On Monday night, the Springfield, MA City Council voted to revoke...read more 

Environmental and human rights activists block off port to stop Forth Energy’s "mad“ biomass plans 17 May 2011
Members of Action Against Agrofuels  blocked the two sole access roads to Grangemouth docks today, in protest over Forth Energy’s plans to build a biomass (wood) burning power station at the docks.

Arrests after protesters bring Grangemouth docks to standstill over power station plans, 16 May 2011 - external link to STV report
The Action Against Agrofuels group staged a protest at Grangemouth docks on Monday morning.

Biomass Firm's Planning Call, 11 May 2011

THE COMPANY behind plans for a biomass plant at Dundee harbour has told ministers...read more

MSPs sign up for biomass plants probe, 18 February 2011 - external link
THERE have been calls for the Scottish Government to carry out a full investigation into the concerns surrounding four controversial biomass plants...read more

Angry exchanges at Leith biomass meeting, 10 Feb 2011 - external link - Report from Wednesday's community meeting between residents and Forth Energy.

SEPA gives its approval for Dundee plant, 13 December 2010 (Word Doc || PDF

SEPA has now given its approval in this report.

CEN to issue draft green standards for biomass, 1 December 2010 - Europe's standardisation body CEN will on Thursday unveil draft sustainability standards for biomass produced for biofuels and bioliquids...read more

Biomass Binge - New Scientist, 13 November 2010

Europe's biofuel plans will produce more greenhouse emissions, not less. So says the first independent analysis of how Europe's 2020 targets will be met....read more

Biofuels Fallacy: Why Burning Plants Instead of Fossil Fuels Won't Save the Climate

The quest to replace black fuels with green fuels is just another resource and land grab by big corporations. While there is no doubt that we need to kick our fossil fuel addiction...read more

Timber firm backs EU-wide protests against subsidies for biomass plants, 30 Oct 2010

Dundee Courier, Saturday 30 October 2010 A Fife timber firm has spoken out in support of Europe-wide protests against biomass plant subsidies...read more

Biomass may emit more CO2 than coal, 27 July

An electrical problem interrupted a Utility and Review Board hearing in Halifax on Monday on a proposed $208-million biomass energy project that critics say is bad for the environment...read more

WHEN THE EU WASTES the CLIMATE: The EU Policy of Subsidising Energy from Burning Waste is Worsening the Climate - June 2010
This work analyses the contradictions of EU (European Union) policy when promoting and funding a false renewable energy - that is, the energy from burning waste. It makes trenchant criticism of biomass burning of forests.

Excessive Subsidies for Waste Wood Incineration, 15 July 2010  - external link to UKwin website

Under the UK’s system for promoting renewable energy technologies – the Renewables Obligation legislation [1] – subsidies guaranteed for years [2] are granted via Renewables Obligation Certificates (ROCs) and are readily available for energy generation that is far from efficient..read more

Incinerator Opponents & Forest Activists Meet Congress to Demand End to Industry Subsidies, 14 July

Activists meet with key Senators & Representatives to expose the environmental, economic and public health risk associated with biomass burning...read more

Delaware closes biomass burning loophole, 2 July 2010

Delaware Senate Bill 311 passed the Senate on June 23rd, 20 "yes" 0 "no" 1 "not voting."  It passed the House on June 29, 36 "yes," one "no."  Hopefully Governor Jack Markell will...read more

BIOMASS INCINERATORS – Separating Fact from Fiction, 3 July 2010 (external link)
Shall we begin by stating that biomass incinerators are rarely, if ever, factually represented by the many sales pitches we see issued by the Energy Industry sector that promotes them. In fact...read more